Quick answer. Choose by the life each trade gives you, because the pay is closer than most people think. In May 2025 the median plumber earned $63,800, the median electrician $63,190 and the median HVAC tech $61,010, according to BLS. Welders earned $53,750, and most work in manufacturing plants. HVAC is projected to grow fastest of the four.
Most lists of the best trades to get into rank jobs by pay and stop there. That's the least useful way to choose between these four, because three of them land within $2,800 of each other at the median.
What actually separates them is the day-to-day. Where you spend your shift and what time the phone rings differ far more than the paycheck does, and so does what your knees feel like at 45. Federal occupation data covers most of it.
The pay is closer than the arguments online
| Trade (BLS occupation) | Median pay, May 2025 | Bottom 10% earned under | Top 10% earned over | Jobs in 2025 | Projected growth, 2025 to 2035 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters | $63,800 | $44,150 | $108,420 | 510,600 | 7% |
| Electricians | $63,190 | $42,640 | $108,510 | 821,000 | 9% |
| HVAC mechanics and installers | $61,010 | $40,050 | $95,210 | 440,900 | 11% |
| Welders, cutters, solderers and brazers | $53,750 | $39,240 | $77,530 | 437,700 | 2% |
BLS groups plumbers with pipefitters and steamfitters, and welders with cutters, solderers and brazers. The gap opens at the top. The best-paid tenth of electricians and plumbers earn more than $108,000, while the best-paid tenth of welders earn more than $77,530. If a six-figure ceiling matters to you, that difference matters more than the medians. Our ranking of the highest paying trade jobs goes further on pay.
Size matters too. Electrical work is the biggest of the four by far, and BLS projects about 72,700 openings for electricians every year over the decade. That's more than plumbing, HVAC or welding, each of which sits near 40,000 to 42,000.
Where you'll spend your day
Electricians mostly work for electrical contractors, which employ 66% of them. The job moves between homes, offices, factories and construction sites, so commuting is part of it, and so are cramped spaces and work at height.
Plumbers are concentrated with plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors, at 65%. Expect heavy lifting, ladders and tight spaces under sinks and floors, with many plumbers driving to a different site every day.
HVAC techs sit with the same kind of contractor, at 68%. Most of their work is indoors, but BLS notes that some techs work outdoors in all weather, and the job can mean cramped spaces and extreme temperatures, like an attic in July or a rooftop in January.
Welders are the outlier. Manufacturing employs 63% of them, against 8% for specialty trade contractors. If you picture welding as pipeline work under a desert sky, the data says you're far more likely to be in a plant, running a shift. Some people love that, since the location is steady and the work is usually indoors. Others sign up for the travel they saw online and end up on a production line.
When you'll work
Electricians almost all work full time, and BLS says overtime is common, including some evenings and weekends. Self-employed electricians, often in residential work, can set their own hours.
Plumbers work full time, including nights and weekends, and are often on call for emergencies. A burst pipe doesn't wait for Monday.
HVAC techs may also be on call, and they sometimes work overtime during peak heating and cooling seasons. Your busiest weeks will likely be the hottest and coldest ones.
Welders in manufacturing usually work shifts. Many plants run two or three shifts of 8 to 12 hours each, so evenings and weekends come with the territory, though the schedule tends to be predictable once you're on it.
What it does to your body
Every one of these jobs is physical, and every one has its own way of hurting you.
BLS lists electric shock, falls and burns for electricians, and notes that accidents can be fatal. Plumbers deal with cuts from sharp tools, burns from hot pipes and solder, and falls from ladders. Welders work around fumes, very hot materials and the intense light of the arc.
HVAC is the one that surprises people. It's often pitched as the gentler trade, but BLS says HVAC technicians have one of the highest rates of injuries and illnesses of all occupations, from electrical burns and chemical exposure to muscle strain from heavy equipment. If someone tells you HVAC is easy on the body, ask them to spend an August afternoon in an attic.
How long until you're earning full pay
Electricians and plumbers usually train through a 4 or 5 year apprenticeship, with about 2,000 hours of paid on-the-job training each year plus classroom work. Most states require a license for both, and the requirements vary by state. Military or construction electrical experience can shorten an electrical apprenticeship.
HVAC techs typically start with a certificate or associate's program lasting 6 months to 2 years, though apprenticeships are another route. The EPA requires technicians who service or dispose of equipment that could release refrigerant to hold Section 608 certification, and BLS says nearly all HVAC techs need it.
Welders need a high school diploma and moderate-term on-the-job training. Even with formal schooling, new welders still get several months of training on the job. Certification comes through professional organizations, and some states and localities license welders.
By my reading, that makes welding the quickest of the four to reach full pay, though its best-paid tenth earns less than in the other three ($77,530, against more than $95,000). For someone who wants steady shift work soon, that can be exactly the right trade.
Could you run your own shop someday?
Self-employment is a minority path in all four. In 2025, BLS counted self-employed workers at 8% of plumbers, 7% of electricians, 6% of HVAC techs and 4% of welders.
Plumbing and electrical have a clear licensing ladder to it. In most states you work toward a journeyman license first, then a master or contractor license, which is usually what lets you pull permits and run your own shop. Requirements vary by state. Welding has the weakest path, since most of the work lives inside factories that need welders as employees.
Match the trade to the life
- You want the biggest job market. Electrical work has the most jobs and the most projected openings.
- You want the fastest-growing field. HVAC is projected to grow 11% over the decade, the most of the four.
- You want full pay soon and a steady location. Welding gets you to full pay fastest, often in a plant on a fixed shift.
- You'll take emergency calls in exchange for steady demand. Plumbing pays at the top of the group, and on-call work is part of the deal.
- You want to own a business eventually. Plumbing and electrical have the most self-employed workers and the clearest licensing path.
Before you commit, spend a day with someone in the trade. A Saturday riding along with an HVAC tech or a week as a helper in a fab shop will tell you more than any table, including this one. If welding is your lean, our guide to how to become a welder covers the training routes.
When you're ready to look
On Qiggz, job seekers browse and apply for trade jobs free, and employers post openings free. Search electrician jobs or HVAC jobs by location.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best trade to get into?
It depends on the life you want. Electrical work has the largest job market, HVAC is projected to grow fastest at 11% from 2025 to 2035, and welding is quickest to start. Plumbing and electrical pay the most at the median and offer the clearest path to running your own business.
HVAC vs electrician, which trade fits better?
It depends on the life you want. HVAC is projected to grow faster, 11% against 9% from 2025 to 2035, and often means on-call work and busy seasons. Electrical work has more jobs and a higher top end, with the best-paid tenth earning more than $108,000 in May 2025, per BLS.
Which trade is hardest on your body?
All four are physical. BLS singles out HVAC technicians as having one of the highest rates of injuries and illnesses of all occupations. Electricians face shock, falls and burns, plumbers face cuts, burns and ladder falls, and welders work around fumes, heat and arc light.
Which trade reaches full pay fastest?
Welding, by most measures. It needs a high school diploma and several months of on-the-job training. HVAC programs run 6 months to 2 years, while electricians and plumbers usually complete a 4 or 5 year paid apprenticeship before full pay.
Sources
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Electricians (2025 pay, work environment, apprenticeship and licensing). https://www.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/electricians.htm
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters. https://www.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/plumbers-pipefitters-and-steamfitters.htm
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Heating, Air Conditioning, and Refrigeration Mechanics and Installers. https://www.bls.gov/ooh/installation-maintenance-and-repair/heating-air-conditioning-and-refrigeration-mechanics-and-installers.htm
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Welders, Cutters, Solderers, and Brazers. https://www.bls.gov/ooh/production/welders-cutters-solderers-and-brazers.htm
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025 national annual wage percentiles for SOC 47-2111, 47-2152, 49-9021 and 51-4121, pulled from the BLS public data API. https://www.bls.gov/oes/




